Peer reviewed analysis from world leading experts

Is Hun Manet Cambodia’s next strongman?

Reading Time: 5 mins
Cambodia's Prime Minister Hun Sen attends the joint news conference of the Japan-Mekong Summit Meeting at the Akasaka Palace State Guest House in Tokyo, Japan, 9 October 2018 (Photo: Reuters/Franck Robichon).

In Brief

The perception that Hun Sen is establishing a family dynasty in Cambodia has been reinforced with the promotion of his eldest son Hun Manet to the second highest rank in the nation’s military last month. The move came after several of the military’s top leaders, including then commander in chief of the Royal Cambodian Armed Forces (RCAF) General Pol Saroeun, resigned in order to stand for political office in the July general election.

Share

  • A
  • A
  • A

Share

  • A
  • A
  • A

Hun Sen’s justification for promoting his son likely extends beyond simple nepotism. Although Hun Sen is still relatively young at 66 — and despite his repeated pledges to remain in power for at least the next decade — health problems have led to a number of trips abroad for treatment. A deteriorating condition could make it difficult for him to retain control of the country effectively.

But surrendering power in an authoritarian regime is a dangerous game. Leaders who do so give up control over the very political, economic and military resources that protect them from prosecution or internal competitors while in office.

Indeed, vulnerability to former opponents and rivals after leaving power is one of the reasons that so few non-democratic states are able to achieve stable, regular leadership turnover. It is also one of the reasons that so many authoritarian rulers try to remain in office indefinitely, only relinquishing power on their deathbed — or at gunpoint.

This concern for what might happen if Hun Sen were to leave power may be one of the driving motivators behind Hun Manet’s promotion. Along with the Prime Minister’s personal bodyguard unit, which is bigger than the militaries of some countries, a close member of the family with extensive military support would make anyone in a post-Hun Sen era think twice about coming after ‘the Strongman’.

If Hun Manet is indeed the designated heir (Hun Sen does have five other children, most of whom are politically active and well connected), his high rank in the military could also help to avert the kind of internal conflict seen last year in Zimbabwe. Competition between military and civilian factions over who would replace the ailing Robert Mugabe played a major role in his downfall. Indeed, Mugabe’s disastrous attempts to promote his wife in his place show that it is absolutely vital for a would-be heir to attract the support of senior elites in authoritarian regimes, with popular support (an area where Hun Manet does not excel) being less important.

At the same time, things may not be as simple as they appear. One puzzle is the question of why changes to the top military hierarchy have been so quick and so extensive. Having disbanded the opposition Cambodia National Rescue Party last year, the ruling Cambodian People’s Party (CPP) was virtually guaranteed victory at the polls. Yet Pol Saroeun — one of the most prominent military figures in the regime since the fall of the Khmer Rouge — and two similarly long-serving and prominent deputies — Generals Kun Kim and Meas Sophea — were nominated by the CPP to step down and run for civilian positions.

The reasons for this sudden move are not entirely clear. In addition, the position of Commander in Chief of the RCAF has gone to the virtually unknown General Vong Pisen, who had only a small public profile in his position as deputy head of the National Military Police (recent stories are limited to his role in policing illegal logging along Cambodia’s border with Vietnam). Even more intriguing is the fact that several special military units formerly under Pol Saroeun’s command were transferred from the control of Vong Pisen to Hun Manet — a move that attracted little publicity.

These hints of a changing distribution of power within the RCAF have led some observers to suggest that Vong Pisen’s new position is ‘merely ceremonial’ — that Hun Manet is now the real force of power in the nation’s military. Together with the marked lack of change within the CPP following the election, others have argued that Hun Sen is making these moves because he still does not fully trust the military or other senior elites outside his own family. Hun Manet’s promotion may therefore be as much about securing Hun Sen’s control over the RCAF as it is about preparing his eldest son to become prime minister.

Even if Hun Manet’s promotion really is just about a future succession, it seems unlikely that he will be ready to take over from his father in the next few years. To avoid the kind of destructive internal divisions that could threaten the CPP’s hold on power in the event of a leadership change, Hun Manet needs to be able to convince senior elites that he is capable of independently retaining control as a strong ruler once his father has left the scene.

Although the boundary between party and military is becoming increasingly blurred, Hun Manet’s military credentials do not automatically equal party support. Whether he is capable of managing the endemic rivalries and factionalism that characterise the party remains to be seen.

There is little positive evidence that Hun Manet has enough support among the Cambodian political elite to hold power on his own any time soon — a change of leadership in the kingdom still seems a distant prospect. For now, it is still Hun Sen’s regime.

Jonathan Sutton is a recent PhD graduate from the National Centre for Peace and Conflict Studies, University of Otago.

2 responses to “Is Hun Manet Cambodia’s next strongman?”

  1. Hun Manet does not hold the “second highest rank in the … military”. As a Lieutenant General (3-star) his rank is under the very many Generals (4-star) in the military. As Commander of the Army he is equal to the other Commanders of the Navy and the Air Force (much smaller and weaker organisation) who are all under the Commander in Chief. Hun Sen already controls RCAF, he does not need his son to do that, but it is safe after he is not PM to have his son in charge of the most of the military.

    • Hun Manet holds the highest rank in the Royal Cambodian Army. As a commander of the Cambodian Army, he occupies great power and has significant influence over other military services such as navy, air force and military police. In Cambodia, army (land forces) with mass majority of personnel (army is around more than 70000, air forces approximately 10000 and navy is around 10000) is the most powerful organisation in the Cambodian defense organisation and playing the most important role in protecting its sovereignty and border protection from invasion as well as effective use to crackdown its own populace as can be seen today at Kompongsom province. Although Manet is just a three star General he is the most powerful general in Cambodia given he is a prime minister’s son. Vireak should understand the Cambodian military system clearly, as it is quite different from Cambodian foreign affairs. As can be seen in the public military events, we can see that many four star-generals are seated at the second row and Gen. Manet is in the first row and presiding over the ceremony. What this means is that it is so strange that four star-generals are under a 3 star general- Manet Hun. It is clearly shown that Hun Manet, despite he is 3 stars general, he is seen as the number man in the Cambodia military- RCAF. As a senior army officer working as RCAF for almost 30 years, I have been exposing in this situation and Manet Hun is the most power general in Cambodia and this is not because he is the brilliant/the best army officer but he is the son of “domestic” strong man Hun Sen.

Support Quality Analysis

Donate
The East Asia Forum office is based in Australia and EAF acknowledges the First Peoples of this land — in Canberra the Ngunnawal and Ngambri people — and recognises their continuous connection to culture, community and Country.

Article printed from East Asia Forum (https://www.eastasiaforum.org)

Copyright ©2024 East Asia Forum. All rights reserved.